eBay Best Offer tips: what to offer, when to offer it, and how to negotiate
A Make Offer button turns a fixed price into the start of a conversation, and the buyers who do well with it are rarely the ones who offer the least. They offer the right number, at the right moment, with a reason the seller can accept. This guide covers how the mechanics work, how to pick a figure, why a listing's age changes the approach, and what to do when the seller comes back with a counter.
By Andrew Galvin, Founder of eSnipe12 min readUpdated
On this page8 sections
- 01How eBay Best Offer works, and the rules that catch buyers out
- 02Fresh listings versus stale ones: two different negotiations
- 03How much under the asking price should you offer?
- 04Seller auto-accept and auto-decline settings
- 05What to say in the offer message, and what not to
- 06Handling counteroffers without overpaying
- 07Timing: when an offer is most likely to be accepted
- 08Offers on bundles and multi-quantity listings
How eBay Best Offer works, and the rules that catch buyers out
When a seller enables Best Offer on a fixed-price listing, you see a Make Offer button next to Buy It Now. You enter a price, optionally a message, and the offer goes to the seller, who can accept it, decline it or reply with a counteroffer of their own. The seller has a limited time to respond; eBay's help pages currently give sellers 24 hours, after which an unanswered offer expires. Counteroffers stay open longer, and eBay also caps how many offers a buyer can make on one item, so every offer you send uses up one of a small number of attempts.
Three rules matter more than the rest. First, an offer is a commitment: if the seller accepts, you have agreed to buy at that price, and you can withdraw an offer only in narrow circumstances that eBay defines. Treat every offer as money you have already decided to spend. Second, the price you offer is for the item; shipping is added on top as listed, so do your sums on the total. Third, and least well known, an accepted offer does not reserve the item. eBay's help pages say the listing stays available to other buyers until you pay, unless you selected a payment method with autopay when you made the offer. If you have negotiated a good price, pay at once, or enable autopay when offering so that acceptance and payment happen together.
Best Offer also runs in the other direction. Sellers can send offers to people who are watching an item, so adding a listing to your watch list is sometimes enough to receive a discount without asking for one. That is worth knowing, but it is not a strategy on its own: a seller who sends offers to watchers usually does so after the listing has sat for a while, and on a well-priced item someone else will have bought it first.
- An accepted offer is a binding agreement to buy.
- Shipping is added to the offer price; compare totals, not item prices.
- The item can still be bought by someone else until you pay, unless you used autopay.
- eBay limits how many offers you can make on a single item, so do not waste attempts.
Fresh listings versus stale ones: two different negotiations
The age of a listing changes the seller's position more than anything else. A listing that has been up for six weeks without selling tells the seller, loudly, that the price is not working. They are often willing to accept a meaningful reduction and may have already dropped the price once. Offers on stale listings succeed because the market has already done the persuading for you.
A listing posted ten minutes ago is the opposite. The seller has just decided on a price and has no evidence yet that it is wrong. They will often decline a big discount on principle, expecting someone to pay the asking price soon. So why offer on fresh listings at all? Because a fresh listing is also the one with no competition yet. Nobody else has had time to make an offer, the seller is at their screen and paying attention, and many sellers are glad of a quick sale at a fair price if it saves them days of answering questions. The goal on a fresh listing is not a deep discount; it is a modest, well-justified one secured before anyone else buys the item outright.
That means the first decision when you see a new listing is whether to offer at all. If the asking price is already under what the item sells for, do not negotiate: use Buy It Now. An offer gives every other buyer who saw the listing time to click the button you did not. Best Offer is for listings that are fair but not exceptional, where a small reduction turns a reasonable purchase into a good one.
| Listing situation | Sensible approach |
|---|---|
| New, priced below recent sales | Buy it now; do not offer |
| New, priced at about recent sales | Small offer with a brief, polite message, sent quickly |
| New, priced well above recent sales | Offer at the sold price and explain why, or wait for it to go stale |
| Several weeks old, no sales | Larger offer is reasonable; the seller has evidence the price is high |
| Already reduced once | Offer near the new price; the seller has already conceded |
How much under the asking price should you offer?
There is no correct percentage, and anyone who quotes one universally is guessing. The asking price is the seller's opinion; the useful anchor is what the same item, in the same condition, has actually sold for recently. Search the item, switch on the Sold items filter, and look at the middle of the last month of sales rather than the extremes. That number is what a reasonable seller should accept, and an offer close to it is one you can defend.
From there, the gap between the asking price and recent sales tells you how much room there is. If the ask is close to the sold middle, a small reduction is all you can expect, and a deep cut will be read as a lowball. If the ask is well above recent sales, an offer at the sold price is reasonable even though it looks like a big discount, because it is not a discount from the market, only from the seller's hope. Mention the comparison in your message and the seller can check it in seconds.
Lowballing has a real cost on eBay beyond the seller's mood. Because you only get a few offers per item, an insulting first offer burns an attempt and may make the seller decline your later, reasonable one. It also wastes the one advantage you had on a fresh listing, which was time. A buyer who sends a fair number in the first ten minutes often beats a buyer who sends a low one, waits for the decline, and tries again an hour later after someone else has paid the asking price.
Finally, work from your own ceiling rather than from the seller's price. Decide in advance the most you would pay in total including shipping, and never offer above it. If the seller's counter lands above your ceiling, the answer is no, however close it is. The discipline matters more than the haggling.
- Anchor on recent sold prices for the same item and condition, not on the asking price.
- Small gap between ask and sold middle: small offer. Large gap: offer at the sold price.
- Count shipping in every comparison.
- Set your own maximum first and never offer or accept above it.
Seller auto-accept and auto-decline settings
Sellers can set Best Offer to respond automatically: offers at or above one figure are accepted instantly, and offers below another are declined instantly. The thresholds are private, the seller can choose to use one, both or neither, and eBay does not publish any typical values, so there is nothing reliable to read about where a particular seller has set them.
What you can read is the speed of the response. An offer declined within seconds, especially in the middle of the night in the seller's time zone, was almost certainly declined by an auto-decline rule rather than a person. That tells you your figure was under their floor, not that the seller is unreasonable, and a modestly higher offer may well succeed. An offer accepted within seconds was likely above their auto-accept line, which is a hint that you could have offered a little less. Do not try to map the thresholds deliberately by stepping up in small increments; you will run out of permitted offers long before you learn anything useful.
A declined offer with no counter from a person who is clearly online is a different signal. It usually means the seller is not ready to move yet, and the right response is often to wait. If the listing is still there in a week or two, the seller's floor may have moved, and you will have offers left to try.
What to say in the offer message, and what not to
The optional message is worth using, briefly. Sellers see many offers with no context, and a single sentence that explains your figure makes acceptance easier. Good messages are short, specific and polite: a note that you can pay immediately, a reference to recent sales at a similar price, or an honest mention of something in the photos that justifies a reduction, such as a missing accessory or visible wear. Sellers are people deciding whether a stranger is reasonable, and a reasonable tone helps.
Some messages reliably backfire. Criticising the item or the price (“nobody will pay this”) puts the seller on the defensive. Long stories about why you deserve a discount read as pressure. Claims that you have seen it cheaper elsewhere without a specific comparison sound invented. And any suggestion to complete the sale outside eBay is both against eBay's rules and a warning sign to the seller that you might be a scammer, which in a sense you would be, since it removes the buyer and seller protections from the deal.
- Do: “I can pay straight away. Similar ones in this condition have sold around this price recently.”
- Do: point to a specific, visible reason for the reduction, such as a missing lens cap or worn corners.
- Don't: insult the item, the price or the seller's judgement.
- Don't: suggest paying or arranging the sale off eBay.
Handling counteroffers without overpaying
A counteroffer means the seller is interested in selling to you, just not at your price. You can accept it, decline it, or counter back, and eBay limits how many rounds of counters you can send. Counteroffers stay open for longer than first offers, but remember the rule from earlier: until you pay, the item is not yours, and another buyer can still purchase it at the listed price. A counter you sit on for a day is a counter you may lose.
The usual pattern is that the seller's counter lands somewhere between your offer and their asking price. If it is within your ceiling, accepting promptly is generally the right move. You were never trying to win the negotiation; you were trying to buy the item at a price you are happy with. Countering again for a trivial sum risks irritating a seller who has already moved and gives other buyers more time.
If the counter is above your ceiling, counter once at your true maximum and say it is your best price, or decline politely. Sellers who receive a clear, final number at a reasonable level often accept it after a little thought, and if they do not, you have lost nothing but a few minutes. The worst outcome is talking yourself past your own limit because the gap seems small. Decide your number before the first offer, and let it decide for you.
Timing: when an offer is most likely to be accepted
Offers are answered by people, or by rules people set, so timing is mostly about the seller's attention. An offer sent while the seller is awake and active gets a considered response; one sent at three in the morning their time sits until they wake up, by which point the listing may have sold. Check the item location before you offer and, where it matters, send the offer during their daytime.
Freshness is the other timing factor, and it argues for speed. On a new listing, the first reasonable offer arrives before any competing offers and before any buyer has paid the full price. Sellers who have just listed are also most responsive, because they are still looking at the listing and their notifications. That is the main reason to hear about new listings quickly: not to get a lower price, but to be the first sensible offer the seller sees.
For listings you would buy at a discount but not at the asking price, an alert is a good fit. Set an eSnipe monitor for the item's keywords with listing type Buy It Now and a maximum price somewhat above what you would pay, since you are expecting to negotiate down, and route it to a Discord channel you check rather than a phone push you must act on instantly. eSnipe's filters cover price, condition, listing type and negative keywords; there is no Best Offer filter, so check for the Make Offer button when you open the listing. And since eSnipe only sends alerts, the offer itself is always yours to make on eBay.
Offers on bundles and multi-quantity listings
Best Offer also works on listings with more than one unit available, and on several items from the same seller. On a multi-quantity listing you can usually choose how many units your offer covers, and sellers are often more flexible on the per-unit price when you take several, since it saves them repeat shipping and handling. Say so in the message, and make sure the quantity you entered matches what you are describing.
When you want separate items from one seller, ask before offering whether they will combine them. Many sellers will create a single listing for the group at a combined price, or tell you what they would accept for the set. That conversation is worth having on eBay's messaging system so the agreement is on record, and the purchase should then go through a normal eBay checkout so it remains covered by eBay's buyer protections.
Questions about eBay Best Offer tips
How much should I offer on eBay Best Offer?
Base it on what the item has sold for recently in the same condition, not on the asking price. If the ask is close to recent sales, offer a little under; if it is well above, offering at the recent sold price is reasonable. Always stay under your own maximum.
Is an eBay Best Offer binding?
Yes. If the seller accepts, you have agreed to buy at that price, and offers can only be withdrawn in limited situations eBay defines. Only offer amounts you are prepared to pay.
Why was my eBay offer declined instantly?
Most likely the seller set an auto-decline rule and your offer was below it. Instant declines are automatic, not personal. A somewhat higher offer may be accepted, but eBay limits how many offers you can make on an item.
Can someone else buy the item after my offer is accepted?
Yes, according to eBay's help pages, unless you enabled autopay when making the offer. The item stays available to other buyers until you pay, so pay immediately after acceptance.
Should I make an offer on a brand-new listing?
Only if the asking price is fair rather than a bargain. If it is already under recent sold prices, buy it outright, because an offer gives other buyers time to purchase it first. On fairly priced new listings, a modest, quick offer works best.